Skip to content
Tamp & Pour

Roundups & reviews · Grinders

Baratza Encore alternatives, ranked

The Encore's real advantage is not the grind, it's that you can still buy parts for it in five years. Six grinders that beat it on range, on price or on grind quality — and what each one gives up.

By Stephen V.Updated How we review
#ad

We earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes a verdict, and we say so when the cheaper product is the better buy. How this works.

The verdict: if espresso is why you are looking past the Encore, the Fellow Opus 2 is the alternative to buy — 48mm burrs, a stepless dial and a genuine espresso range, which is the one thing the standard Encore cannot do at any setting. If you want the Encore's job done for less, the OXO Brew Conical Burr covers the same brewed range with real conical burrs and a dose timer for well under it. The budget pick is the SHARDOR Professional Conical Burr, the cheapest electric here that is genuinely a burr grinder. One warning that shapes this whole page: almost none of these alternatives match the Encore on the thing that actually makes it a ten-year purchase.

So start there. The Baratza Encore is a 40mm conical burr grinder with 40 stepped settings, a deliberately low-speed drivetrain, and a range that runs from cold brew through to fine drip. Its finest setting is not fine enough for espresso, and Baratza says so — the Encore ESP exists for exactly that reason. What makes the Encore the most-recommended first grinder in home coffee is none of those specs. It is that Baratza publishes its parts, sells replacement burrs, and supports the machine for years, so a dulled burr set or a failed gearbox is a repair rather than a landfill trip. That is unusual at this price and almost unheard of below it.

People look past the Encore for three reasons, and they want different answers. Espresso: the single most common one, because the Encore simply does not reach it and no amount of tamping fixes a grind that gushes. Price: the Encore is not expensive for what it is, but it is not the cheapest way into burrs either, and plenty of drip drinkers do not need forty settings. Grind quality: 40mm conical burrs are good, not exceptional, and if you brew filter coffee daily and nothing else, there is a clear step up available.

The ranking below is by how well each grinder answers one of those three, then by what it costs, then by repairability. We rank repairability last here only because it is the criterion the Encore wins and the alternatives mostly lose — so leading with it would make the page a list of six grinders you should not buy, which is not useful. Instead it is stated on every pick that gives it up. Every pick already appears somewhere on this site; specifications, pros and cons are carried over unchanged from those entries, with the source page named in each pick's body. The Encore ESP is deliberately not a pick, because it is the same machine line rather than an alternative to it — that decision lives on Baratza Encore vs Encore ESP.

The short answer

Quick picks

  • 01
    Fellow Fellow Opus 2
    Fellow Opus 2

    The alternative that does the one thing the Encore cannot: 48mm conical burrs with a stepless dial and a specified espresso-to-cold-brew range, built around single dosing rather than a hopper.

    7.7Best if you need espresso
  • 02
    OXO OXO Brew Conical Burr Grinder
    OXO Brew Conical Burr Grinder

    The cheaper swap that does the Encore's actual job: real conical burrs across the brewed range, 15 settings plus micro-adjustment, and a timer that remembers your dose — for well under the Encore.

    7.5Best cheaper alternative
  • 03
    Breville Breville Smart Grinder Pro (BCG820)
    Breville Smart Grinder Pro (BCG820)

    The alternative with the widest reach: 60 settings, a timed dose on an LCD, and enough fine range to feed an espresso machine — plus it grinds straight into a portafilter, which the Encore cannot.

    7.2Best for a dose timer and espresso reach
  • 04
    Fellow Fellow Ode Gen 2
    Fellow Ode Gen 2

    The alternative that beats the Encore at its own game: a 64mm flat burr, single-dose loading and very low retention, aimed at exactly the drip and pour-over range the Encore was built for.

    7.8Best grind quality for filter only
  • 05
    Timemore Timemore Chestnut C3 ESP
    Timemore Chestnut C3 ESP

    The hand-grinder answer: stainless conical burrs with a genuine espresso-capable fine range and essentially zero retention, for well under the Encore — at the cost of cranking it yourself.

    8.2Best cheap espresso-capable swap
  • 06
    SHARDOR SHARDOR Professional Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (48 settings)
    SHARDOR Professional Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (48 settings)

    The budget pick: the cheapest electric here that is genuinely a burr grinder with real adjustment, at a fraction of the Encore — with the build and retention compromises that price implies.

    6.3Budget pick

#ad · Live prices from the Amazon Product API, as of November 19, 2026. Where we have no verified live price, we show none — a gap beats a number that has rotted.

In detail

The picks, in full

01
Fellow Fellow Opus 2

Best if you need espresso

Fellow Opus 2

48mm stainless conical burrsStepless side dial100 g load bin, 100 g catch cup, 30 g espresso cup300 W, anti-static ionizer, tool-free burr access2.3 kg, 2-year warranty
7.7/10

The alternative that does the one thing the Encore cannot: 48mm conical burrs with a stepless dial and a specified espresso-to-cold-brew range, built around single dosing rather than a hopper.

Answers an Encore limit
9
Grind quality
7.5
Retention
8
Repairability
6
Value
7.5

Pros

  • Specified across an espresso-to-cold-brew range, and ships with a 30 g dosing cup Fellow states fits 54mm and 58mm portafilters
  • Stepless adjustment is the mechanism that makes dialing in an espresso shot possible at all
  • 48mm burrs clear a dose in fewer rotations than the Encore's 40mm, so grinding is faster and the coffee picks up less friction heat
  • Built around single dosing — a 100 g load bin and matched catch cups — so switching beans does not carry stale grounds forward the way the Encore's hopper does
  • Integrated anti-static ionizer genuinely reduces fine grounds clinging to everything they touch

Cons

  • Fellow publishes no grind range in microns on its own product page — the 200-1200 micron figure that circulates comes from retailer listings, not from Fellow
  • No motor RPM and no noise figure published, so there is nothing to compare against the Encore's published low-speed drivetrain
  • Fellow's page describes a stepless dial while its own FAQ cites 48 adjustable settings, so the documentation is not consistent about whether the dial detents
  • Two-year warranty, and nothing like Baratza's decade-deep parts and repair ecosystem behind it — this is the Encore advantage you are giving up
  • A stepless dial is harder to return to exactly than counting clicks, so switching between espresso and filter costs you a few seconds each way

Don't buy this if…

…you brew only filter coffee and always will. You are paying a bracket more than the Encore for an espresso range you will never use, and the Encore makes drip, pour-over and French press just as well for less.

Who it is for: the reader who was about to buy an Encore and then bought an espresso machine. Specifications, pros and cons are carried over unchanged from our Baratza Encore vs Fellow Opus comparison, which goes through this grinder's documentation gaps in detail. It is the top pick because it answers the Encore's single hard limit rather than its soft ones: a grinder that cannot go fine enough to choke an espresso machine cannot be dialed in at all, and the Encore cannot. Two honest qualifications. The 48mm burr buys throughput and less friction heat rather than a step change in uniformity — eight millimetres is a real but modest advantage. And you are trading Baratza's parts catalogue for a two-year warranty, which over a decade is a genuine cost. If espresso is not in your future, buy the Encore and keep the difference.

$159.95View on Amazon

$199.9520% off

Price as of November 19, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Fellow Opus 2

02
OXO OXO Brew Conical Burr Grinder

Best cheaper alternative

OXO Brew Conical Burr Grinder

Stainless conical burrs15 settings plus micro-adjustmentsOne-touch timer, remembers your settingBrew-range grinder (not espresso-focused)
7.5/10

The cheaper swap that does the Encore's actual job: real conical burrs across the brewed range, 15 settings plus micro-adjustment, and a timer that remembers your dose — for well under the Encore.

Answers an Encore limit
7.5
Grind quality
7.5
Retention
6
Repairability
5
Value
9

Pros

  • Burrs rather than blades, which is the entire point — and the same brewed range the Encore covers, at a clearly lower price
  • The timer remembers your setting, so grinding fresh becomes a single button press rather than a decision — the Encore has no timer at all
  • Covers the full brewed range from French press to drip and pour-over comfortably
  • Cheap enough that it pays for itself against the premium you stop paying for pre-ground specialty coffee

Cons

  • Not an espresso grinder — the fine end of its range is not consistent enough for a nine-bar puck, exactly like the Encore
  • Fifteen settings is coarse resolution next to the Encore's forty, so you live with a nearer approximation on any given bean
  • Hopper grinding means retained grounds between doses and a small purge if you switch beans
  • No published parts or burr-replacement program, so a dead grinder is a replacement rather than a repair

Don't buy this if…

…you make espresso. This grinder is built for brewed coffee, and espresso needs finer, more repeatable adjustment — see our espresso grinder picks instead.

Who it is for: the reader whose objection to the Encore is simply the price. Specifications, pros and cons are carried over unchanged from our best grinders for drip coffee ranking. This is the most honest cheap swap on the page, and it is worth being precise about what it is: it is not a worse idea than the Encore, it is a narrower one. Same category, same ceiling, fewer settings, a timer the Encore lacks, and no repair story. For a reader with one bean and one brewer, the fifteen-settings limitation may never surface and the timer is a daily convenience. For a reader who changes beans weekly, the Encore's forty steps are what the extra money buys.

$98.98View on Amazon

$109.9910% off

Price as of November 19, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to OXO Brew Conical Burr Grinder

03
Breville Breville Smart Grinder Pro (BCG820)

Best for a dose timer and espresso reach

Breville Smart Grinder Pro (BCG820)

Conical burrs, 60 settingsTimed dosing with LCDGrinds into a container, portafilter or filter basketHopper-fed
7.2/10

The alternative with the widest reach: 60 settings, a timed dose on an LCD, and enough fine range to feed an espresso machine — plus it grinds straight into a portafilter, which the Encore cannot.

Answers an Encore limit
8
Grind quality
7
Retention
6
Repairability
5.5
Value
7.5

Pros

  • Sixty settings is the finest resolution of any hopper grinder on this page, against the Encore's forty
  • Reaches espresso fineness, so unlike the Encore it does not strand you if you buy a machine later
  • Grinds directly into a 54mm portafilter with the included cradle, or into a paper filter basket — no transfer step and no static mess
  • Timed dosing gets you close to a repeatable dose before you own a scale, which the Encore does not offer

Cons

  • Doses by time rather than weight, and time-based dosing drifts as beans age, as the hopper empties and as the burrs season
  • Espresso-capable is not the same as a dedicated espresso grinder — step resolution is adequate rather than fine
  • Hopper-fed, so switching beans means either purging or living with a blend of the old and new
  • No parts-and-burrs program on Baratza's terms, so repairability is a step down from the Encore

Don't buy this if…

…you already own a Barista Express, Pro or Touch. Those have this grinder built in — buying it again gains you nothing, and the money belongs in a tamper and a scale.

Who it is for: the Breville owner, and the reader who wants one grinder that will cover filter now and espresso later. Specifications, pros and cons are carried over unchanged from our best grinders for pour over ranking. It sits third rather than higher on a trade-off worth naming: against the Encore it adds espresso reach, a timer and twenty more settings, and it subtracts the repair path and some of the Encore's low-speed drivetrain advantage. Against the Opus 2 it is a hopper grinder rather than a single-doser, which matters if you rotate beans. If you own a Breville machine, the portafilter cradle alone tilts it — our best grinders for Breville espresso machines page covers that case specifically.

$199.95View on Amazon

Price as of November 19, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Breville Smart Grinder Pro (BCG820)

04
Fellow Fellow Ode Gen 2

Best grind quality for filter only

Fellow Ode Gen 2

64mm flat burrSingle-dose loadingVery low retentionBrew-only range
7.8/10

The alternative that beats the Encore at its own game: a 64mm flat burr, single-dose loading and very low retention, aimed at exactly the drip and pour-over range the Encore was built for.

Answers an Encore limit
7
Grind quality
9.5
Retention
9
Repairability
6.5
Value
7

Pros

  • The cleanest, most even grind for pour-over and drip we recommend — a 64mm flat burr is a different class of machine from a 40mm conical
  • Quiet, compact and beautiful — a design object as well as a tool
  • Single-dose loading suits someone who rotates beans, and retention is very low where the Encore's hopper holds grounds between doses
  • Fellow's own statement is clear about what it is for, so the fit is easy to judge

Cons

  • Cannot grind for espresso — the range does not go fine enough, and Fellow says so itself, so it shares the Encore's single hardest limit
  • Expensive for a brew-only grinder, and well over twice the Encore
  • Single dosing means weighing beans for every brew rather than filling a hopper
  • Two-year warranty rather than Baratza's parts-and-burrs program

Don't buy this if…

…there is any chance you pull espresso. Fellow itself says the Ode is not for espresso; the Opus 2 or the Encore ESP covers both for less money.

Who it is for: the filter-only drinker who has used an Encore for years, knows exactly what they brew, and wants to stop upgrading. Specifications, pros and cons are carried over unchanged from our Fellow Ode Gen 2 review. It is the highest-scoring grinder on this page on the two criteria that matter most for drip and pour-over, and it is fourth, which needs explaining: it costs well over twice the Encore and it shares the Encore's hard limit, since it cannot make espresso either. So it answers the soft complaint about the Encore (the grind is good, not exceptional) at considerable expense, while leaving the hard one untouched. If the grind is genuinely what bothers you, this is the right buy. If you were hoping one purchase would also unlock espresso, it will not.

$319.95View on Amazon

$399.9520% off

Price as of November 19, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Fellow Ode Gen 2

05
Timemore Timemore Chestnut C3 ESP

Best cheap espresso-capable swap

Timemore Chestnut C3 ESP

Stainless S2C conical burrEspresso-capable fine rangeAluminum bodyTravel-friendly
8.2/10

The hand-grinder answer: stainless conical burrs with a genuine espresso-capable fine range and essentially zero retention, for well under the Encore — at the cost of cranking it yourself.

Answers an Encore limit
8.5
Grind quality
8
Retention
9.5
Repairability
6
Value
9

Pros

  • Reaches espresso fineness, which the Encore cannot, for less money than the Encore costs
  • Essentially zero retention: what you put in comes out, where every hopper grinder on this page holds some back
  • Good enough for filter as well as espresso, so it is not a single-purpose purchase
  • Compact, handsome and travel-friendly — it goes in a bag, which no electric here does

Cons

  • Manual, so a full pot of drip coffee is genuine work — this is the Encore's real advantage for a filter drinker
  • Small capacity per grind, so brewing for several people means several rounds
  • Hand grinders are slower to switch between espresso and filter settings than a numbered external dial
  • No parts-and-repair program comparable to Baratza's

Don't buy this if…

…you grind for a carafe every morning, or anyone else in the house uses the grinder. Hand grinding a 60g dose for a Chemex is a workout, and that is exactly the job the Encore does effortlessly.

Who it is for: the one-or-two-espressos-a-day drinker who wants to spend less than an Encore and get a capability the Encore does not have. Specifications, pros and cons are carried over unchanged from our best gifts for coffee lovers ranking, and the category in full is in best manual coffee grinders. The honest comparison with the Encore is a fork rather than a ladder. For espresso, this is better and cheaper. For a 10-cup drip machine, the Encore is better by a mile, because you press a button instead of cranking for two minutes. Which of those describes your mornings decides this entirely, and our manual vs electric coffee grinder page works through the trade.

$68.00View on Amazon

$99.0031% off

Price as of November 19, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Timemore Chestnut C3 ESP

06
SHARDOR SHARDOR Professional Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (48 settings)

Budget pick

SHARDOR Professional Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (48 settings)

Conical burr48 grind settingsTimed dosingEspresso through French press range
6.3/10

The budget pick: the cheapest electric here that is genuinely a burr grinder with real adjustment, at a fraction of the Encore — with the build and retention compromises that price implies.

Answers an Encore limit
6
Grind quality
6.5
Retention
5
Repairability
3.5
Value
8.5

Pros

  • 48 steps give far more granularity than the 12-to-15-step electrics around it, and more than the Encore's 40
  • Burrs rather than blades at a fraction of the Encore's price, which is the whole upgrade for anyone currently using pre-ground coffee
  • Timed dosing and a removable grind chamber make daily use simple
  • Cheap enough to buy alongside a brewer rather than instead of one

Cons

  • Plastic-heavy construction; not a grinder you keep for a decade, which is precisely the Encore's whole proposition
  • Fine settings are usable but not precise enough to dial a non-pressurized espresso shot
  • Static cling at fine grinds means grounds stick to the chamber
  • No published burr diameter, so there is no way to compare it on the one spec that matters most

Don't buy this if…

…you own a machine with non-pressurized espresso baskets — for real espresso you need repeatable micro-adjustment this cannot deliver.

Who it is for: the reader for whom the Encore is simply not in the budget this month. Specifications, pros and cons are carried over unchanged from our best budget coffee grinders ranking. It is the budget pick because it is the cheapest thing here that does the actual job — crush beans between two burrs at a size you choose — and it is last because it loses the Encore comparison on every axis except price. Worth saying plainly: the gap between this and a blade grinder is enormous and you will taste it tomorrow; the gap between this and the Encore is build, repairability and consistency, and you will notice it over years rather than days. If you can wait and save, wait and save.

$59.99View on Amazon

$79.9925% off

Price as of November 19, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to SHARDOR Professional Conical Burr Coffee Grinder (48 settings)

What you are actually giving up

The Encore is not the best-grinding machine in its price class and it has never claimed to be. It is the most recommended one, and the reason is worth stating before you replace it.

The repair story is the Encore's real feature

Burrs dull. Motors and gearboxes fail. Baratza publishes parts, sells replacement burr sets and supports its machines for years, so a tired Encore is usually a repair rather than a replacement. Of the six alternatives on this page, none has an equivalent program — most offer a two-year warranty and then goodwill. That difference does not show up in a spec table and it is worth real money over a decade, which is why it is named in the cons of every pick above. If you intend to own one grinder for ten years and you brew filter coffee, the honest answer may well be to buy the Encore and stop reading.

Forty settings in the range you actually use

Total step count is the most over-quoted grinder spec, because where the steps sit matters more than how many there are. The Encore spends all forty of its clicks between cold brew and fine drip, so the settings a filter drinker moves between are close together. A grinder advertising sixty settings across espresso to French press has wider gaps in the brewed range even though the number is bigger. Keep that in mind when the Smart Grinder Pro's sixty looks like an obvious win: it is a win on reach, not necessarily on resolution where you brew.

Pick your alternative by which limit you hit

If you need espresso

This is the hard limit, and it is the one reason to replace an Encore rather than keep it. A grinder needs a genuinely fine range andincrements small enough to move a shot from thirty seconds to twenty-five without landing on fifteen. The standard Encore has neither. Your list is the Opus 2, the Smart Grinder Pro and the Timemore C3 ESP — and the cheapest route of all is the one this page deliberately excludes, the Encore ESP, which is the same machine with espresso burrs and a different adjustment range. If espresso is your only complaint, read Baratza Encore vs Encore ESP before you leave the brand.

If you need it cheaper

The OXO is the closest equivalent for less, and the SHARDOR is the cheapest thing on the page that still has burrs. Both give up the repair path, and the SHARDOR gives up build quality too. Our best budget coffee grinders ranking covers that whole bracket, and best coffee grinders under $200 is the ladder the Encore sits on.

If you want a better grind for filter

Then you want a larger, flatter burr, and the Ode Gen 2 is the clear answer. Be realistic about the size of the improvement: moving from a 40mm conical to a 64mm flat narrows the particle distribution and reduces fines, which shows up most in a paper-filtered drip basket where fines clog the bed and extend contact time. It is a real improvement and it is not a transformation, and it costs well over twice the Encore. Our conical vs flat burr grinders page explains what geometry actually changes.

If retention is the problem

Every hopper grinder, the Encore included, keeps a few grams in the chute between doses, so the start of today's brew is the end of yesterday's bag. If you drink one bean from one bag, this is invisible. If you rotate roasters, it is the reason single-dose grinders exist, and on this page the Opus 2 and the Ode are built that way while the Timemore holds essentially nothing at all. Our best single dose grinders ranking covers the format.

Three reasons not to replace it yet

Your burrs may just be dull. An Encore that has ground a few hundred pounds of coffee grinds visibly worse than a new one, and a replacement burr set costs a small fraction of any grinder here. That is the whole point of buying a repairable machine, and it is the first thing to check before concluding you need a different one.

It may need cleaning rather than replacing.Coffee oils build up on burrs and in the chute, and dark roasts accelerate it. A grinder that has never been cleaned tastes stale regardless of what it is — how to clean a coffee grinder covers the routine.

The brewer may be the weak link. If your coffee is thin and sour with a correct dose and a medium-roast bean, the problem is more likely brew temperature than grind. A machine that publishes no temperature figure and carries no certification is the usual culprit, and best coffee makers under $200 is where that changes. Replacing a working Encore will not fix a cool brewer.

How we picked

We did not lab-test this gear

Everyone in this category says they tested twenty machines. We have not lab-tested any of these, and we say so. What we did instead: compiled the published manufacturer specifications, read the manuals, ran the math where there was math to run (heat-up time, pressure, dose capacity, grind range, cost per cup), and scored each pick against a published rubric. The scores are judgments from documented research — not measurements we took, because we do not have a lab and we will not pretend we do. Where a number came from someone else's work, we name them in Sources.

Questions

Frequently asked

What is the best alternative to the Baratza Encore?
It depends on which limit you hit. For espresso, the Fellow Opus 2 — 48mm burrs, a stepless dial and a specified espresso range, which the standard Encore does not have at any setting. For the same job cheaper, the OXO Brew Conical Burr. For a better filter grind, the Fellow Ode Gen 2. All three give up Baratza's parts-and-burrs repair program.
Is there a cheaper alternative to the Baratza Encore?
Yes. The OXO Brew Conical Burr covers the same brewed range with real conical burrs and adds a dose timer, for clearly less. The SHARDOR 48-setting conical is cheaper again. Both are replacements rather than repairs when they fail, which is the trade.
Can the Baratza Encore grind for espresso?
No — its finest setting is not fine enough, and Baratza does not claim otherwise. The Encore ESP is the same machine with espresso burrs and a reworked adjustment range, and it is the cheapest route to espresso if you are happy to stay with Baratza. Outside the brand, the Opus 2, the Smart Grinder Pro and the Timemore C3 ESP all reach it.
Is the Fellow Ode Gen 2 an upgrade over the Encore?
For filter coffee, yes: a 64mm flat burr produces a narrower particle distribution and fewer fines than a 40mm conical, which matters most in a paper-filtered drip basket. It is not an upgrade in capability — Fellow states the Ode is not for espresso, exactly like the Encore — and it costs well over twice as much.
Why does everyone recommend the Encore if better grinders exist?
Because of repairability and range placement rather than raw grind quality. Baratza publishes parts and sells replacement burrs, so the machine is serviceable for years, and its forty settings all sit in the brewed range where a filter drinker actually works. Most grinders at or below its price offer a two-year warranty and nothing after it.
Should I replace my Encore or just replace the burrs?
Try the burrs first, especially if the grinder has done a few hundred pounds of coffee. A replacement burr set costs a small fraction of any grinder on this page, and a dull burr set is the most common reason an old Encore grinds worse than it used to. Clean the chute while you are in there.

Keep reading

Receipts

Sources

We do not run a testing lab, and we do not pretend to. Where a measured number came from someone else's work, we name them and link them. Where we could not verify something, we say so on the page rather than quietly leaving it out. Read our full method.